Thursday, February 09, 2006

Cartoons, Faith, & Extremism

So buildings are being torched and people are being killed because of some offensive cartoons? Hmm. I don't mean to be all "they hate us for our freedoms" or anything, but WTF? I can certainly understand being offended by people violating your religious laws, and I can understand the need to express that through just about any means, but why would one get violent over it? I imagine there's more going on here and that the hostility has been seething for a while now, but I can't imagine that Muhammad would really be this pissed off to say that you should kill someone over his depiction. More to the point, so what if he does? I think that's a sign that maybe the religion has some, say, problems. Now, I know enough Muslims that I don't believe that most Muslims are really inclined to kill or harm over such things, but all religions get trouble when they try to be literal or fundamental. There are just too many contradictions.

It's the same with just about any religion, which, frankly, drives me further and further from them. Nietzsche respected Christ but not Christians, and I can identify with that perspective. I have grappled with the notion of faith in general. On the one hand, it means trusting in the unknown. But how does one know where to put one's faith in that case? It seems a bit like a crapshoot. I guess you just feel it, but what happens when other people feel it differently?

I think about people who freak out over things like cartoons. At what point do you decide that God wants you to kill over the thing, and at what point do you say, "That's not really my thing, so this isn't the religion for me"? That's a human choice, but it seems sensible to me. Maybe I just don't have enough faith.

But then, what about morons like E's ex who are afraid of numbers like 666 and stuff? I think that's similar to the cartoon issue, because if your faith is really so strong, then it shouldn't be affected by such superficial things. Maybe I'm trying to be too rational (although my argument might not be so rational) and I'll pay the eternal price, but I just can't make myself believe something on that level.

When it all comes down, I suspect that all the potential gods are pretty disappointed right now.

Tuesday, February 07, 2006

Penn Jillette, Genius; Also, Faith

Nice article here on Slate about the intellectualism of Penn Jillette. I've long loved Penn & Teller, and their promotion of skepticism really fits my worldview and my teaching philosophy, even if I do have faith in some things that they don't. But it's faith, and I think it's ok to have it, as long as you know what it is... and isn't.

For example, in BullShit, their genius show, they claim that there's no evidence that secondhand smoke is unhealthy. Well, as much as I trust numbers, I think their assessment of the data was a bit limited, so I keep faith that they're wrong. Not that I'm certain that they're wrong, but I believe they're wrong. I'm still skeptical, and willing to be corrected.

As I tell my students, the scientific approach is the best way to know something, but that doesn't mean we have to abandon our beliefs. We just have to acknowledge that they're beliefs. To claim positivity in things unproven is troublesome because it doesn't allow for potential disconfirmation. I don't know that anyone's religious beliefs are *definitely* wrong, but they don't know that they're *definitely* right either.

Anyway, read the Penn thing.


I don't think it's quite appropriate for people like me to profess to know whether the wiretapping procedures the preznit is defending are legal or not. Although they sound illegal, there are always some nuances that keep me from being able to judge. Sure, I'm inclined against the taps because of who's doing them, but that isn't enough.

Still, this article from the NYTimes seems to spell things out pretty well. We know that Gonzales is a lackey for Bush, who likes his AttyGens close, loyal, and fascist. Here he's saying that the law granting Bush war powers essentially trumps far more specific laws in place previously. So is anything verboten given these war powers? Perhaps, hitting kittens with hammers?

Monday, February 06, 2006

Get Back, Coretta...

The greatest editorial writer in the country (my strongly held opinion before he won the Pulitzer), Leonard Pitts of the Miami Herald, wrote an interesting column on the passing of Coretta Scott King. Although I stand by the praises I extended her way (appreciated, I'm sure), I can't counter Pitts' much-more-informed take.

He takes his privileged position to criticize some of the more money-grubbing nuances of how the King family has treated MLK's legacy. I guess he was stating concerns I've had from what I've read but haven't felt comfortable mentioning. From my position, I'm not entitled to do so, but Pitts is, and, as usual, he does so with eloquence.

'Hawks Win! Thoughts on Rush

Don't want to make too much of it, but the Jayhawks aged about 2 years during their game Sunday, as did I. For them it was good, but not for me and my rapidly increasing grayness quotient.

After hanging tough for the 1st half or so, OU took momentum into halftime and proceeded to whip our asses through most of the 2nd half. But then the youngsters took over and got the job done. I'm an optimistic person, so I hadn't completely written them off, but 16 down with 10 minutes left against a good and well-coached squad can't look good. Still, I recall one 3-pointer by Brandon Rush as a sign that things had the potential to turn.

And turn they did. Fantastic energy and quickness stepped up the defense against OU, and we gradually chipped away at the lead by smothering the Sooners as they'd done to us before. Still, I've seen comebacks before, so I was beginning to come to terms with the moral victory of not getting pasted, but it's hard to get over the hump in a comeback, even at home. Still, they did it. Came close to icing it without sending my heart into overtime, but OU still had a shot with 1.6 sec left. Good foul by KU (smart to eat clock because they weren't in the bonus--had to do it fast before the act of shooting), followed by a good no-call by the official got us out with the 1-point win.

Man, did that feel good. I rode the high all day. Still, we're unranked, and we'll be inconsistent all year (contradiction?) I expect, but maybe we can keep it going into the tourney and do some damage. If we make it (looking pretty good now), I'll pick them to win it all, as every year. They're a great group, and I'm looking forward to watching them develop--the beauty of college hoops.

Speaking of "develop," Rush is looking more like a star and a leader than I thought he would at this point. Still, it's premature for him to go pro. I know he's chomping at the bit, but he's no Carmelo (1 & done). He's a great college player, and he may be a great pro, but I really hope, and not just for my own fan's sake, that he gives us at least another year. He's not dominant, but he's very good. Make it last, man!

I have a theory that once all these guys who go pro at 18 or so get to retirement age, they'll regret missing so much of the college hoops experience. The NBA is fine, I guess, but I'll take the passion of guys who really care over the rote moves of megaliths and mega-egos any day. Once the money's in the bank and hasn't solved all their problems, they won't see it as their salvation anymore. 'Course, I don't know what I'd do if I had the chance. I just hope that some of our signees have the character and perspective to consider their long-term happiness. Injuries are a risk, sure, but career-enders are increasingly rare, and again, even that wouldn't mean the end of a basketball career of some sort.

Come on Brandon, listen to Danny. He stayed 4 years, and he wouldn't be back helping you along if he didn't know what the college game really is.

Dude, WTF?

Not sure why the TB4NO post below got re-posted with this date. I posted that several weeks ago, so pay no attention. We'll see what happens with the Saints, but I must say I'm extraordinarily excited to be back in the Dome in September. More Saints posting to come.